317 vs 317L Stainless Steel: How Low Carbon Changes Welding and Corrosion Behaviour

Jul 28, 2025

Leave a message

Two Molybdenum Grades, One Decisive Difference

When engineers compare 317 and 317L stainless steel, they are looking at a single alloy chemistry offered with two carbon specifications. Chromium, nickel and molybdenum levels are identical; the "L" suffix signals a maximum carbon content of 0.030% against 0.08% for the standard grade. That single number decides how the material behaves after welding, and it is the reason specification documents usually name 317L for fabricated equipment and reserve 317 for unwelded parts.

Composition and Pitting Resistance

Both grades are austenitic stainless steels with a molybdenum addition in the 3-4% range, which separates them clearly from 316L at 2-3% Mo. Composition limits per ASTM A240 are summarised below.

Element 317 317L 316L (reference)
Carbon (C) 0.08 max 0.030 max 0.030 max
Chromium (Cr) 18.0-20.0 18.0-20.0 16.0-18.0
Nickel (Ni) 11.0-15.0 11.0-15.0 10.0-14.0
Molybdenum (Mo) 3.0-4.0 3.0-4.0 2.0-3.0

With PREN = Cr + 3.3 Mo + 16 N, both 317 and 317L score about 33 to 35, while 316L reaches roughly 24 to 26. The extra molybdenum is what buys additional tolerance for chlorides, and the extra chromium and nickel widen the passivation window in mildly reducing acids.

Corrosion Performance in Service

Annealed samples of 317 and 317L are effectively interchangeable under chloride attack. The distinction emerges in three situations:

As-welded structures: 317L holds its intergranular corrosion resistance without heat treatment; 317 may sensitise in the heat-affected zone.

Elevated temperature: Type 317 retains marginally higher strength and creep resistance, which suits hot non-welded components.

Severe chloride duty: Neither grade suits continuous seawater immersion or hot concentrated chloride brines, where higher-alloy or nickel-based options are required.

Mechanical and Physical Behaviour

Property 317 317L
Tensile strength, min 515 MPa 515 MPa
Yield strength (0.2%), min 205 MPa 205 MPa
Elongation in 50 mm, min 40% 40%
Typical service temperature Up to about 800 degrees C in oxidising service Up to about 400 degrees C where sensitisation matters

Ductility is similar in both grades, and both are readily cold formed, though their high work-hardening rate calls for more bending force than 304 or 316 requires.

Welding, Forming and Machining

Welding 317L with a matching low-carbon filler metal produces joints that need no post-weld heat treatment. Weld 317 with controlled heat input, and plan a solution anneal where the service is aggressive. For cold forming, allow generous bend radii because the austenitic structure work hardens quickly; an intermediate anneal restores formability for severe draws. Machining is best performed on annealed stock using positive-rake tooling, sharp edges and a continuous coolant supply, since the material tends to glaze and work harden under light rubbing cuts.

Where Each Grade Belongs

Type 317 suits non-welded chemical processing hardware: valve bodies, pump shafts, orifice plates and machined fittings that operate at moderately elevated temperature. Type 317L suits welded equipment exposed to chlorides and dilute acids, including welded storage tanks, offshore process piping, flue gas desulfurisation vessels and industrial wastewater treatment systems. The selection rule is simple: if fabrication involves welding and the environment contains chlorides or dilute acids, the low-carbon grade is the correct choice.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the main difference between 317 and 317L?
Only the carbon limit. Type 317 allows up to 0.08% carbon and Type 317L allows up to 0.030%; chromium, nickel and molybdenum specifications are the same.

Q: Why does low carbon matter for welded parts?
Low carbon prevents chromium carbide precipitation at grain boundaries in the heat-affected zone, which is what protects weld-adjacent metal from intergranular corrosion.

Q: Does 317L have higher strength than 317?
No. ASTM A240 lists the same minimum tensile strength of 515 MPa and yield strength of 205 MPa for both grades.

Q: Can 317L be used in seawater piping?
It performs well in brackish and cooling water circuits, but continuous seawater immersion with crevices needs a higher molybdenum content than 317L provides.

Q: Is post-weld heat treatment needed for 317L?
Normally no. The low carbon content keeps the weld and heat-affected zone resistant to intergranular attack without annealing.

Q: Which grade should be specified for a welded chemical tank?
Specify 317L. Welded tanks exposed to chlorides or dilute acids rely on the low-carbon chemistry to keep the weld zone corrosion resistant in service.

Send Inquiry